Hi Ya,
I have had both during my 11 years spent on Scooby Island
2 Civic Type Rs & 5 Imprezas (Type R Import,Uk Turbo,Uk Sti7,Import Sti8 & The First Hawkeye Import in Europe!)
All good cars, but once in a Good Impreza, you will never go back especially living where you do.
With the budget you have finding a good car should be easyish, go for the newist you can afford (personal opinion) BUT do not rush, there are so many available, get yerself down to Barry Currans (to try Not buy ) and get a feel for the car, there are also plenty of good local guys who i would no doubt take you out in there cars to also get a feel as to how Different they all are.
Sadly, i am no longer on the island nor have a scooby anymore, but good luck in finding a car.
Ta Ta
Richard