Hmm. I think the comparison is valid. I enjoy driving as a rule and obviously the Impreza has more of everything - power, grip, etc... But driving home from work on some random Thursday afternoon during the rush hour, bumper to bumper all the way, it's not really gonna matter what you're driving. I mean, there's not a lot of driving pleasure to be taken from that.
Don't get me wrong, I'd love an Impreza, but it's one of those heart says yes, head says no situations simply because I don't think it'd be very sensible from a financial standpoint.
No one has really talked about having to make sacrifices and that, frankly, makes it all a bit of a head-scratcher for me. A lot of you on this forum seem to be over 25, so surely you must have a mortgage or rent to pay, on top of bills and loads of other expenses besides your car. How do you manage it? Have you taken out loans? Are you in debt? What about savings? Aren't you WORRIED that, despite the pleasure it brings you, it's mostly dead money when spending on cars?